If that was true for Black Panther and Shuri as well, then it supports the theory that they weren't really dead, because otherwise T'Challa at least would have been on the Ancestral Plane during the five-year period. He understands this when he looks at Doctor Strange. Marvel Provides More Evidence Thanos Is Alive After Endgame - Screen Rant The truth is that this probably wasn't intentional; it's the kind of oversight that inevitably slips in when a franchise has been running for over a decade, albeit quite a dramatic example. Because it means Thanos and his armies aren't really dead at all. The plan would have worked, but instead of capitalizing on their advantage, Starlord squanders it by attacking Thanos, dislodging Mantis and her sedating effect from his brow, and the Mad Titan unleashes his full fury against the assembled combatants. The way the heroes vanished in Avengers: Infinity War wasnt just made that way to make the audience cry theres a lot more to it, both in-universe and behind the scenes. Answer: only if the dustings started before the Snap. The substituted Stones will work well enough singly, on a small scale, but as they are out of phase (like Ghost, in a sense), so they will fizzle when used for anything major Like the Snap. No trace of Tony. He went on to explain that they had concept art combining different ideas, but in the end, it all came down to body turns to ash, and so they peeled away all those layers and focused on that one [Power Stone] and how quickly it would consume someone. There are some very bold statements here about what various characters were thinking. Signifying what he told him before, there is only one way and that's to let Thanos win in Infinity War. This will hinge upon not interfering with Thanos acquisition of each Infinity Stone, just making sure Thanos does not get any of the Stones that are actually native to the MCUs universe. Todays deals: $4.50 smart plugs, $100 off AirPods Max, $65 smart TV, GE Opal ice makers, more. For Thanos at the end of the movie, this is part of his Heros Journey, we once again put him face to face with the only thing that he cared about, where he has to own up to the emotional cost of what hes done in the movie.. And it is clear that Doctor Strange means for Tony to die, and although Tony does not understand it immediately it seems to me that even the authours assume that he understands it when Strange tells him "if I tell you it won't happen". Marvel has punked us all, Reddit user Knight3rrant explains. The Avengers had just had a desperate fight with Thanos over the Gauntlet in which Thanos won, Tony just sneakily beat him. The Mad Titan believed that explosive population growth threatened to result in a universal extinction-level event. For more information, please see our Much improved. But while we wait for the movies to hit theaters, well show you a mind-blowing new theory that says the snap never happened the way Thanos thought it did. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. At the heart of all this is the simple question of what really happened in the two snaps the one inAvengers: Infinity War, and the one inAvengers: Endgame. There were other means available to the Illuminati of Earth-838, who defeated their Thanos with the Book of Vishanti, or perhaps that was an option after 15 million potential losses. As evidence, the Redditor offers the fact that the decimation begins in New York soon after the attack on Wakanda starts. So how was he able to see past his own death? What's the difference between Hulk's snap and Tony's then? And even if they did run off, where to? All Rights Reserved. 17 17 comments Top Add a Comment cpancoast 1 yr. ago Thanos didn't come back- he came from the past. Why couldn't he just run off with the stones for the moment? All Thanoss snap did was severely damage the Infinity Gauntlet and convince the Mad Titan that he had completed his lifes work. part of the Terran army, but apart from that, given his pretty strong will to survive, was there an immediate reason for him to go for the snap right then and there? At that moment, the enormity of what he is saying is too vast for them to reconcile. But it does create this cathartic moment for him.. I don't think that's why. This means Strange considered two different possibilities. The place to drop your theories and memes about the MCU. Its likely similar things happened everywhere on Earth and other planets, meaning that people who have survived the snap may have been killed in the accidents the snap caused. One of the conditions of Tony's involvement in the Time Heist was that when they recovered all six Stones from the various timelines, there would be no alteration of the past five years so that his daughter's life would be protected. Outside of work, youll catch him streaming almost every new movie and TV show release as soon as it's available. When the story . Why can C not be lexed without resolving identifiers? In the same kind of way, the snap appears to have deconstructed people right down to a molecular level. In the end of the day it was Tony that wanted Bruce to snap everyone back and not change what had happened so why would Tony then go and change the past for another version of himself and not give the alternate version of himself the chance that he had. Question: Why did Tony stark choose to die when he could have - Reddit Avengers: Infinity War saw Thanos snap his fingers and apparently kill half the life in the universe - but that may not have been the the case at all. If this is the case, then there's no reason to assume Thanos is gone for good from the MCU. BGRs audience craves our industry-leading insights on the latest in tech and entertainment, as well as our authoritative and expansive reviews. At the beginning of Avengers: Endgame, the remaining heroes from the Guardians and the Avengers seek out Thanos on a world known as the Garden, a place Nebula said was the constant destination her father always discussed once his plan was complete. I could be totally wrong but I had to put this down somewhere and if I need to rethink it I'd rather be told than going around being an MCU idiot for the rest of my life Tony looks at Strange while he is windmilling the water or whatever, and Strange lifts up one finger. Because hes in the Heros Journey in the movie, we did point that out that theres a correlating journey in the film between Thor and Thanos. Why didn't Hulk's snap kill Thanos and his army? : r/marvelstudios - Reddit Tony could recall her name being mentioned then. Avengers: Endgames Ending Has Some Disturbing Implications, No More Time Stone In The MCU Is Dangerous News For Doctor Strange 2, the souls were transported to the Quantum Realm, Kevin Feige Answers 11 Burning Questions About Endgame & The MCU's Future, Every Upcoming Marvel Cinematic Universe Movie, James Bond 26 Poster Art Makes A Strong Case For Top 007 Shortlist Contender, 10 Live-Action Superhero Suits Ruined By CGI, Anthony Mackie Addresses Jonathan Majors' Arrest, Is First MCU Actor To Comment. RELATED: Doctor Strange 2 Warps WandaVision Into Something More Sinister Than a Tale of Grief. 'Avengers: Endgame' theory reveals why only Iron Man could stop Thanos That bit of honor proved to be his undoing. She reveals Thanos' main goal is "to wipe out half the universe . After his first snap, could Tony Stark or any of the Avengers use the He certainly. In Avengers: Infinity War, Doctor Strange doesn't seem to get nearly enough credit for how he engineered the one option out of millions to save the lives of half the Marvel Cinematic Universe. All rights reserved. Why does the present continuous form of "mimic" become "mimicking"? Cookie Notice The Chitauri Leviathans are living beasts, so it makes sense, but the Outrider Dropships are clearly mechanical, as seen in Avengers: Infinity War.. We did not see this with the snap in Avengers: Infinity War, where. I felt like at that moment when Strange lifts up his finger Tony finally got it. That means there's even a theoretical possibility Thanos could come back, despite what happened in Avengers: Endgame. This is supported by the writers Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely in this interview. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! What's the meaning (qualifications) of "machine" in GPL's "machine-readable source code"? BGR is a part of Penske Media Corporation. You don't need universe-scale impacts like the original snap required. All rights reserved. Tony's snap set everything up so that Infinity War would play out just as it had. Why Thanos Didn't Just Kill All of the Avengers in Infinity War - CBR The Ancient One had protected reality itself by using the Time Stone to explore countless alternate futures, identifying threats and working out how best to deal with them. Australia to west & east coast US: which order is better? How is it that in the Endgame Super Bowl TV spot everyone on Earth are mourning the dead if no one really died? Also, just because the Avengers ultimately win doesnt mean itll be without any sacrifices, which is something the theory doesnt cover. Also, Tony was risk adverse to the whole time heist, and wanting to avoid risking his family. Strange wasn't asking for Tony's life to be spared out of any sense of camaraderie; he was trying to ensure that Tony would be around to save everyone, himself included. What Exactly did Tony's snap do Everything I have been reading makes me confused about what Tony did. BRUCE BANNER: We don't. It almost killed him. Did Tony Stark's snap in Avengers Endgame send everyone from Thanos In the midst of the raid on the Avengers' compound, Hawkeye attempts to protect Hulk-gauntlet, but he eventually gives it up to Nebula . He confirmed his suspicions that one of his other children, Black Maw, was dead before speaking to his vision of the universe. Why didn't Hulk's snap kill Thanos and his army? The new trailer for Avengers: Infinity War features a key piece of information courtesy of Gamora. Update crontab rules without overwriting or duplicating. Defeat Thanos' army conventionally, or just hand off the Gauntlet to The Hulk who can actually survive? We guide our loyal readers to some of the best products, latest trends, and most engaging stories with non-stop coverage, available across all major news platforms. Related:Kevin Feige Answers 11 Burning Questions About Endgame & The MCU's Future. Answer (1 of 5): When Tony Stark did his Snappening the cry of his heart and soul would've been "SEND THAT BIG PURPLE BASTARD AND HIS BASTARD FRIENDS TO HELL!! Strange uses the Time Stone to see like a lot of possibilities (don't remember exact number) and says that, in only one of them do the Avengers win. The lighting briefly changes after the Hulk's snap, in the scene where the Hulk looks at the birds in the tree, indicating that this additional dust has been extracted from the atmosphere again. It was the winning outcome as well. However he went about it, he needed to kill Tony as he intended before Strange stopped him from doing so since Tony was the only mind capable of creating time travel in an afternoon. Quill makes that choice on Titan when he punches Thanos in the face. The way the bodies turned to ashes was also carefully planned to add more drama to each fallen heroes final moments for example, Grootwas reaching out to Rocket, but as legs and arms vanished first, Rocket could never hold his hand. This energy pattern is stored in a memory buffer, then transmitted to another point, where it is converted back into matter. There's been intense speculation as to whether or not Thanos actually died, though, and whether he could potentially return. That wasn't just a convenient special effect, either; look closely at the post-snap world ofAvengers: Endgame, and you'll notice that the lighting levels are slightly darker. Everything I've read, people seem to think that Tony just disappeared them, like Thanos originally did to half of everyone else. Tony would have to sacrifice his life, to miss out on his daughter's future. [caption id="attachment_705270" align="aligncenter" width="600"], The Russo Brothers Explain Why Scarlet Witch Lost Her Accent in 'Infinity War', Infinity War Directors on Why Those Trailer Scenes Arent in the Movie, Avengers: Infinity War Actor Hints that [Spoiler] Is Really Dead and Gone. Fortunately, of course, the Avengers were able to put the matter to rights. Presumably even the bodies of fallen Chitauri and Outriders crumbled away. He snapped his own fingers, sacrificing himself to turn Thanos and his armies to dust. and our Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. If Dr Strange knew the outcome why did he put up the fight? Related:Avengers: Endgames Ending Has Some Disturbing Implications. Why risk it? And I'm happy for you, I really am. from FanTheories. snaps the Infinity Gauntlet v2, all of Thanos's ships also get disintegrated. It may have taken time and a lot of death, but at some point, Thanos . The "five years later" time jump is another five years after 2018, when the majority of the film is set, and the film explicitly says that 2014 was "nine years ago." Thats where directors Joe and Anthony Russo decided to take Infinity War, which culminates in Thanos gaining all six infinity stones, snapping his fingers, and wiping out half the population of the entire universe. Hes seen three snaps happen with the Gauntlet and his is relatively minor in comparison. The decimation that we saw at the end of Avengers: Infinity War wasnt real, according to this theory.